I think both games are different enough you don't need to compare them, and I really like both. Though, I'd say I might side more on Bloodborne. Really hope it gets a sequel or a spiritual successor.

As for the Lovely Level-up Ladies, the Fire Keeper is sadly disappointing. She's not even really a character, she's just…. there… Barely talks to you and her entire purpose seems to only effect a single ending. Hopefully the DLC can give her a bit more love.

I love both Bloodborne and Dark Souls but for this I will have to side with the hunters since the fast and aggressive style fits with how I play in some games.